(HINT: It’s not free when somebody else is paying the bills.)
I just read a blog post by Steve Wagenheim where he talks about being banned from the Warrior Forum for a week. What a pity, but I have to agree with his analysis.
Somebody started a thread meant to be a tribute to the recently deceased Michael Jackson (whose death was, in my mind at least, a tragedy. We lost a tremendous entertainer and pioneer). Personal allegations aside (and I’d like to point out that they were just allegations, and in the United States, you are generally presumed innocent until proven guilty), he simply did some stuff in his prime that were amazing. I was really hoping that he could put together a comeback tour (I saw the posters in London when I was there a couple of months ago) and once again do some amazing things. It’s tragic when Big Pharma and their promises of Utopia in the form pharmaceuticals cuts down someone as brilliant as Michael Jackson (just as it is tragic when they cut down anybody. Don’t you think God would have put chemicals in our bodies when He created us if we really needed them?).
At any rate, as seems to be the case a lot lately at the Warrior Forum, a few people apparently turned the thread into a personal attack on Mr. Jackson (I trust Steve’s judgment here; I didn’t read the post because I unfortunately have problems connecting to the forum). Steve says that he jumped in and called these people on it, and apparently used some language that was a bit over the top, at least by forum rules.
And in spite of his tens of thousands of posts there, and the thousands of times he has publicly been acknowledged for his help, he got banned for a week.
A few points here:
- Speech is not free as long as somebody else is paying the bills. Remember this when at a forum and always respect the rules (or expect the consequences).
- Most forums are full of people who either genuinely need help or genuinely want to help. Try not to comment on a given forum post unless you fall into one of those two categories.
- Don’t stir up trouble on purpose in forums, especially popular ones that get lots of traffic (like the Warrior Forum). Moderators and owners might have time to discuss “transgressions” with you on smaller forums; you will most likely get the rules thrown into your face without warning on larger ones.
- Don’t look to me as the “poster child” for 100% proper forum behavior. I do try to behave, though, and make it a point to never attack people, but I will discuss issues and share my experiences on a topic, good or bad…
- A blog (with a link to the forum post in question) is a good way to vent steam, so to speak, without circumventing forum rules (but then the thing appears in a public place with your name on it, so make sure you don’t write something you’ll regret later. Sure, you can change your blog post, but it gets archived in its original form in LOTS of places under normal circumstances).
- Don’t let the forum trolls get you down. Try to focus on the people who really want help while ignoring the electron thieves.
And one final, unrelated one from me:
- Don’t use the private messaging system to send out spam to other members. We didn’t join the forum to get PMs for some affiliate product you’re pushing!
In this case, sadly, Steve let the forum trolls get under his skin, and as a result, a good forum has lost input and help from one of the most prolific writers in Internet Marketing circles for a week. Personally, I think that Steve is taking it quite well and I applaud him for his openness and willingness to post a “warning” about it on his blog.
But do remember that there’s no such thing as free speech in an Internet discussion forum; you have to follow the rules of whoever is paying the bills (or their designated agents).
P.S. — Steve, I didn’t even realize that you have a blog until your email to your list about this issue… As expected, you seem to be posting to it several times daily — and I always enjoy your unique take on things. But I was wondering if there is some reason why you don’t allow comments?